Welcome back!
You’ve returned to this recipe. Save it to your personal Recipe Box so you won’t have to search for it again.
Free for 30 days. No payment information required.
Nutter Butter Pie
At a Glance
- Total
- 1 hr 8 min
- Servings
- 6.00 serving(s)
Categories
- Dessert
- Pie
- Bake
- Chill
Allergens
- Milk
- Peanuts
- Wheat
- Soy
Servings & Nutrition
Original recipe serves 6. Current scale: 1x.
Nutrition and servings are approximate based on the ingredient list. Please verify for dietary or medical needs.
This recipe for Nutter Butter Pie brings together 16 ounces cream cheese, 1 cup peanut butter, 3/4 cup powdered sugar in a practical dish for home cooking. It takes about 1 hr 8 min to prepare and cook. It makes approximately 6 servings.
Hands-Free Mode Off
Want to make this later?
Save this recipe to your personal Recipe Box and find it whenever you need it.
Free for 30 days. No payment information required.
Plan This Meal for Later
Create your free My Kitchen account
Start your free 30-day trial and we’ll add this recipe to your meal plan automatically.
No payment information required.
Equipment
Big bowl, electric mixer, 2 zip-top bags, rolling pin or wooden spoon, medium bowl, 9-inch pie pan, oven, freezer
Ingredients
- 16 ounces cream cheese
- 1 cup peanut butter
- 3/4 cup powdered sugar
- 1 tablespoon vanilla
- 2 (1 lb) packages Nutter Butter sandwich cookies
- 1/4 cup butter
- 8 ounces Cool Whip
- 2 ziploc bags
- 9 inches pie crusts, pan
Send These Ingredients to My Shopping List
Create your free My Kitchen account
Start your free 30-day trial and we’ll add this recipe to your shopping list automatically.
No payment information required.
Instructions
Preheat oven to 350 degrees F & Get a Big bowl.
Mix cream cheese, peanut butter, powder sugar and vanilla with electric mixer on medium speed until well blended.
Take your ziploc bag enter 1 package of Nutter Butter into Ziploc,.
Try to press as much air out of the bag as possible, and tightly seal it shut.
Using medium force, break the cookies with the rolling pin or woodenspoon.
Continue crushing the broken pieces until you are left with coarsely crushed crumbs(chucky not fine dust lol).
Then Fold into same mixture bowl.
In New bowl open your 2nd package of cookies and sperate the filling and the cookies put the cookies in your 2nd ziploc bag.
(optional) When done mix filling with spoon and add in your mixture bowl.
Now take your ziploc bag of cookies and crush them finely & evenly.
In a medium bowl, mix together crumbs and melted margarine. Place mixture in a 9 inch pie pan and press firmly into bottom and sides of pan.
Bake in preheated oven for 8 minutes & Allow to cool.
Spoon your mixture into your pie crust & spoon your whip cream topping on top of the filling.
(optional) Garnish with remaining nutter butter cookies and crumb the edges of the pie.
Before serving put it in the freezer for one hour And Devour.
Keep Cooking
More Pie Recipes
Want more ideas? Browse the full recipe collection.
Find more recipesTurn this recipe into a complete meal
Ask Your Kitchen Concierge to find sides, desserts or other recipes that work with this dish.
Advertisement
Reviews, cook notes, and substitutions
No member notes yet. Public visitors can read notes here once members share them.
Log in with an active membership to leave a review or share cook notes and substitutions.
Keep exploring
What would you like to make next?
Turn this recipe into dinner Ask Your Kitchen Concierge to suggest a main course, side and dessert using recipes already on Shared Recipes Club.
